Coffee knowledge· 5 min read·
Co-fermented coffee: why we keep it honest
Strawberry, lychee, melon… Some co-fermented coffees taste literally of them. We looked at what the labs found inside, and why at Chronic. we keep our coffee free of tricks.
Why we don't sell flavoured coffee, even when it wins competitions.
In 2023, a coffee used at the World Barista Championship by a very highly ranked competitor went under a chemist's microscope. Inside: melonal. A molecule that smells of melon and has never been found naturally in a coffee bean. Alongside it, a solvent and a stabiliser. In other words, the recipe for a food flavouring.
Melon is delicious. In a competition cup presented as pure coffee, it goes down less well.
At Chronic., we've made our call, a bit like when we said no to pods. Our coffee has no tricks. What you drink comes from the plant, the producer's work, the fermentation and our roasting. Full stop. Here's why it matters to us, and what it changes for you.
Fermentation, co-fermentation, added flavouring: where's the line?
After harvest, the coffee cherry ferments. Always. For a few years now, producers have learned to steer this stage: selected yeasts, temperature, oxygen, time. It's real craft, and it produces fruitier, more winey, more expressive coffees. If you want the details of the methods, from washed to anaerobic, we've laid it all out in the secrets of coffee fermentation.
Some go further and put fruit or spices in the tank. That's called co-fermentation. And that's where you come across coffees that no longer evoke strawberry or lychee. They taste of them, literally, like a sweet.
The catch is that a fresh fruit aroma shouldn't survive a roaster that climbs to around 200 °C. Pergamino, a Colombian producer and exporter, ran the test. Green coffee fermented with mint or lemongrass smells very strong before roasting, then loses most of it coming out of the drum. With fruit or wine yeasts, it becomes fruitier. Never "strawberry".
In the food industry, there's a known way to make a fragile aroma withstand heat: dissolve it in a carrier solvent, often propylene glycol (E1520). That's exactly what people went looking for in these coffees.
The rules are a grey area. The WBC only bans additives after the green coffee stage. Cup of Excellence only accepts water in its experimental category. Best of Panama disqualified four infused coffees in 2024. Everyone does their own thing.
What the labs found (and what they didn't prove)
Two investigations dug into the subject, with two very different methods.
The first is Swiss. Ennio Cantergiani runs the Académie du Café in Chardonne and works on the chemistry of aromas. He's the one who analysed the WBC 2023 coffee, presented without any mention of infusion. He used GC-MS, the reference tool in flavour labs, which identifies molecules one by one.
| Molecule found | What it is |
|---|---|
| Propylene glycol | Carrier solvent for flavourings |
| Melonal | Melon aroma, never identified in coffee |
| Melonal acetal | Reaction product of melonal and glycol |
| BHT | Antioxidant that stabilises flavourings |
| Ethyl maltol | Synthetic caramel aroma |
The molecule, its solvent, its stabiliser: that's the spec sheet of a commercial flavouring. The acetal is the giveaway. It forms when melonal and glycol spend time together, so probably before reaching the coffee. The limitation is that it's a single, unnamed coffee whose analysis circulated on a forum. ZHAW made a similar finding on a green coffee that smelled of aniseed.
The second is Colombian. Pergamino, in Medellín, announced in June 2026 that it would not sell co-fermented coffees. With the Universidad Surcolombiana, they ran 25 co-fermented coffees from 8 sites through near-infrared spectroscopy (NIR), alongside washed coffees. NIR gives an overall chemical fingerprint of the green bean without destroying it. The result: the two groups separate without error, the difference falls on a band typical of glycols and polyols, and the co-fermented coffees sort into eight subgroups that the authors read as eight recipes.
On Instagram, Pergamino claimed that all 25 coffees contained propylene glycol. The paper doesn't say that. NIR picks up a family of chemical bonds, not a molecule or a dose. Some polyols, like glycerol or mannitol, are normal by-products of fermentation, especially with fruit and sugar. The only controls are washed coffees, with no "clean" naturals or anaerobics, and the abstract mentions 79 controls while the method describes nine. Eight sites, eight groups: that could also simply be where the lots came from. Finally, no peer review, anonymous lots, and an author with a commercial interest in the debate.
A Reddit thread summed it up better than we can: NIR tells you a coffee is different, not why. The study that would settle it would do both, an NIR screening of traceable lots followed by GC-MS on the suspects. The expertise exists in Switzerland, between the Académie du Café and ZHAW.
Why we say no
Let's be clear: we have nothing against experimentation. Selected yeasts, controlled fermentations, co-fermentation with real fruit: all of that is part of the craft, and some of our exceptional coffees go through very carefully worked fermentations. What bothers us is added flavouring that isn't disclosed.
First, because you have the right to know what you're drinking. Swiss law already makes the distinction for beer: "raspberry beer" when the fruit was fermented or macerated, and "raspberry-flavoured beer" as soon as a flavouring is used (FDHA Ordinance on Beverages, art. 66). Coffee isn't mentioned. We're not lawyers, but the same logic seems obvious to us, and the question deserves to be put to the cantonal laboratory.
Second, because it destroys what gives a coffee its value. If a melon taste can be bought by the drum, there's no need for altitude, a rare variety or ten years of work on a plot. Pergamino says it bluntly: the advantage will shift from terroir to those with the means to industrialise flavour. Our Seasonal and Exception ranges come from very small producers, like Pepe Jijón in the Intag valley. They earned their flavours. We're not going to pit them against a bottle.
And it's consistent with everything else. No pods. No aluminium in our bags. Specialty coffees, roasted every day, never shipped more than a month after roasting. We'd rather make less noise and have everything be real. An honest coffee is the same idea applied to the cup.
One last point, quieter but important to us: we don't want you to get used to sweets. A washed Ethiopian that evokes jasmine isn't a failure because it doesn't taste of jasmine syrup. That's the whole point.
What we do in practice
Before buying a fermented lot, we ask for the full details of the process: what goes into the tank, how much, and when. If a fruit, yeast or spice has been added, it's written on the bag. If the origin of the aromas remains unclear, we don't buy, even when the coffee shines on the cupping table. And our tasting notes describe what a coffee evokes, not a promise of candy. To learn how to decode them, see how to read a coffee label.
How to spot a flavoured coffee
None of these clues is proof. But if several add up, it's worth a question to your roaster.
The green coffee already smells strongly of jasmine, rose or cinnamon, even before roasting. The dominant note doesn't budge an inch, whether roasted light or darker. The ground coffee keeps an intense fragrance for months, while a normal coffee fades quickly. Your grinder keeps the smell after the lot has gone through. And the note matches the advertised fruit exactly, candy-style rather than fruit-style.
A good coffee changes from one roast to the next, from one week to the next, from one method to another. It's alive. That's what we love, and that's what we'll keep serving you.
Your questions answered
Frequently asked questions
What is co-fermented coffee?
Is co-fermented coffee the same as flavoured coffee?
How can you spot a flavoured coffee?
Why doesn't Chronic. sell flavoured coffee?
Do your coffees go through special fermentations?
Roasted in Geneva